An Ontario Superior Court judge has ruled Canada cannot remove the option of returning land to Saugeen Ojibway Nation (SON) as a remedy from the second phase of a treaty claim.
SON says it should be entitled to ownership of 651 parcels of land, through constructive trust that are currently owned by Canada or Ontario on the Bruce Peninsula. SON is not looking for privately owned land.
This is in preparation for a remediation trial set for late 2030 or early 2031, establishing remedies after the court ruled the Crown had breached its honour in regard to treaty 45 1/2 with Saugeen Ojibway Nation.
According to Waters’ Law of Trusts in Canada, “a constructive trust is a vehicle of equity through which one person is required by operation of the law, regardless of intention, to hold certain property for the benefit of another.”
Canada had made a preliminary motion arguing for the removal of the land back remedy, saying it should not apply and that a constructive trust is a private law remedy. it submitted that in the absence of a breach of fiduciary duty, there is no basis in this case to award a constructive trust over the lands at issue in Phase 2.
Justice Wendy Matheson ruled November 10th, “I conclude that the high threshold required to succeed on a preliminary motion… is not met at this time, despite compelling arguments in favour of the position that the claim for land will fail. There appear to be material facts in dispute. I cannot rule out the possibility, however small, that the Phase 2 evidence may displace the conclusion I would otherwise draw, granting this motion. The motion is therefore dismissed.”
- Court Releases Decision On Saugeen Ojibway Nation Title And Treaty Claims
- SON Chiefs Walk Out Of Court Hearing In Frustration
- Saugeen Ojibway Nation Continues Treaty Claim Court Battle
The Treaty Claim is about the Crown’s Treaty 45 ½ promise to protect the Peninsula for the Saugeen Ojibway Nation from settlers. In 1836, the Crown asked SON to open up their lands in their Territory south of Owen Sound, and in exchange, they promised to protect the lands on the Peninsula from the encroachment of settlers forever.
In 1854 the Crown broke that promise, saying that it could not protect SON’s lands, and that the solution was to open up the lands on the Peninsula for sale to settlers.
The result was Treaty 72. In 1994, SON brought a claim in the Ontario courts, saying the Crown broke its treaty promise to protect the Peninsula and so breached its honour.
In 2021, the Ontario court issued a decision confirming there was a breach of the honour of the Crown, and also ruled the Crown had no fiduciary duty to protect the peninsula.
That decision was upheld in 2023 by the Ontario Court of Appeal.





Comments